U.S. Hand-Off Begins – Europe On The Hook

Delegates seated around a circular conference table in a large chamber
Photo: lev radin / Shutterstock

Europe’s security order is already shifting from an American-led subsidy model to a European-led responsibility model; the only real question is whether Europeans turn higher budgets into the hard capabilities that close their still-critical gaps.

The Short Version

  • European defense outlays have surged, creating fiscal room for a European-led security design and greater responsibility in Europe’s own theater.
  • Washington’s policy has moved from gentle burden sharing to explicit burden shifting: Europe must carry primary responsibility as U.S. priorities rebalance.
  • Analysts across institutions agree Europe still relies on U.S. “strategic enablers” — intelligence, lift, missile defense, long-range strike, C2 — that money alone has not yet replaced.
  • The durable solution is a stronger European pillar inside NATO: Europeans lead more, spend smarter, and close enabling gaps without severing transatlantic integration.

Why a redesign is coming — and why Europe should lead it

The case for recalibrating Europe’s security order is not ideological; it is arithmetic and strategic. European governments have opened the fiscal taps, elevating defense spending to levels that make leadership plausible rather than rhetorical. In 2025, EU member states spent €418 billion on defense — about 2.2% of EU GDP — a 20% jump in a single year, with projections to €454 billion in 2026. This is the resource base European leaders have long lacked. At the same time, U.S. strategy is moving from exhortation to expectation. In his Naval War College remarks, Secretary of War Pete Hegseth stated plainly that the era of American-subsidized European defense is ending and that allies must assume primary responsibility for their own theater under President Trump’s guidance and the 2026 National Defense Strategy. Put simply: Europeans now have both the money and the mandate.

Taken together, these shifts argue for Europeans to lead the redesign of their security architecture — inside NATO, alongside the United States, but with Europeans setting requirements, owning timelines, and bearing risk. That is the essence of what Trump’s envoys are pressing: not a romanticized “strategic autonomy” detached from reality, but a governed transition in which Europe becomes the first responder on the continent while the transatlantic bond remains the backbone.

Mechanism: from budgets to capabilities to command

Defense orders of battle are not balanced sheets; money becomes power only when converted into enablers, munitions stocks, readiness, and command-and-control. Here the record is mixed and drives the most credible counterarguments. The Council on Foreign Relations catalogues Europe’s dependence on U.S. strategic enablers — space-based ISR, integrated air and missile defense, long-range strike, strategic lift, logistics, cyber, industrial depth, and intelligence fusion. Carnegie reaches a similar conclusion: any “purely European” arrangement would face near-term shortages of these very enablers now provided through NATO by the United States. The European Parliamentary Research Service adds the command-and-control and nuclear dimensions: no EU battle management system today can run territorial defense at scale; Europe remains reliant on U.S. nuclear deterrence and satellite infrastructure.

These are not reasons to freeze the status quo; they are the to-do list. A serious European pillar must prioritize: joint air and missile defense layers; long-range precision strike; air- and sealift plus prepositioned logistics; trusted, sovereign ISR across space, air, and cyber; resilient C2 with interoperable data fabrics; and munitions production at industrial scale. The DGAP is correct that burden-sharing percentages are a poor proxy for usable power; closing the enabling gaps is the metric that matters.

History and trajectory: burden sharing’s newest turn

Calls for “Europeanization” are not new. What is new is the combination of political intent in Washington to shift burdens and the magnitude of European spending increases now in train. The cyclical pattern — U.S. pressure, European pledges, partial follow-through — is giving way to a more consequential phase because Russia’s war stripped away wishful thinking and because fiscal choices have already been made at scale. EU figures confirm eleven consecutive annual increases, culminating in 2025’s surge to €418 billion, with further growth queued for 2026. The opportunity cost of not translating this into operational capability is now too high to ignore.

American strategy, too, has evolved. Hegseth’s formulation — Europe bears primary responsibility for its conventional defense; the United States remains the alliance’s ultimate backstop — aligns with a number of transatlantic analyses that favor a stronger European pillar of NATO rather than a clean separation. CSIS frames it explicitly as complementarity: allied self-sufficiency and continued U.S. leadership are not mutually exclusive but mutually reinforcing pillars of a resilient deterrent system. That logic matches the alliance’s practice: Europeans leading more missions and capabilities inside a NATO framework preserves interoperability and political cohesion while lightening the American lift.

Where the real debate lies: separation versus separability

The sharpest analytic dispute is not whether Europeans should do more — they should — but whether Europe ought to design a defense system separable from the United States or genuinely separate from it. The Carnegie assessment argues for “separable, not separate” governance: Europe must be able to operate without the U.S. in a pinch, yet remain tightly coupled to U.S. capabilities in normal times. The Centre for European Reform reaches a hard-edged corollary: neither an EU-centric defense nor a NATO construct with drastically reduced U.S. participation could, today, fill the resulting capability gaps; command structures and C4ISR still lean on the United States. These positions are not refutations of a European-led redesign; they are constraints that discipline it.

In practice, the path that squares capability, politics, and time is a European pillar inside NATO with explicit milestones for enabler substitution. Europe leads the land-heavy conventional deterrence mission along the eastern flank; invests jointly in air and missile defense, long-range strike, and a common logistics architecture; and develops command arrangements “separable” from U.S. command in extremis but optimized for integration in peacetime. That is achievable within this decade if budgets continue and procurement is reformed to favor speed, commonality, and scale.

Turning money into power: priorities and pitfalls

Three priorities will determine whether Europe’s fiscal surge hardens into credible force.

First, enablers over prestige platforms. The war in Ukraine has been a masterclass in what modern high-intensity warfare consumes: ISR constellations, electronic warfare, counter-UAS, layered air defense, precision fires, and rivers of ammunition. Buying more of yesterday’s armor without the kill chains, air defenses, and sustainment to protect and feed them misallocates scarce euros. The European spending base can fund the shift; political leaders must insist on it.

Second, industrial scale and joint procurement. Europe cannot close gaps with boutique production lines and fragmented orders. Multi-year, multi-nation contracts for interceptors, missiles, and artillery ammunition — with assured financing and common specifications — are the only way to drive costs down and volumes up. Analysts warn plainly: Europe’s deterrence will be weakened if the United States reduces support before these industrial and logistical ecosystems mature.

Third, command, data, and readiness. Deterrence credibility flows from command authorities, rehearsed plans, and live readiness — not just inventory counts. Europe needs interoperable C2 that can ingest allied ISR, task shooters rapidly, and survive contested electromagnetic and cyber environments. The EU cannot today run a full-spectrum territorial defense operation; NATO can, but relies heavily on American officers and systems. Building dual-hatted, European-led command constructs within NATO, with robust exercises and war reserves, is the bridge.

The bottom line: Europe should carry more — and can, if it closes the enabler gap

Trump’s envoys are right on the core point: Europe’s security order must change so Europeans assume greater responsibility, design more of their own architecture, and lead more of the day-to-day deterrence mission on their continent. The financial capacity is arriving at speed; the U.S. policy environment now pushes in the same direction. The counterarguments are not an indictment of the goal but a checklist for execution: until Europe fields the enablers Washington now provides, any abrupt U.S. retrenchment would create dangerous seams.

The durable settlement is a Europeanized NATO: Europeans in the lead for Europe, transatlantic integration preserved where it multiplies strength, and a deliberate program to substitute critical enablers on a schedule the budgets can support. That is not a slogan; it is a work plan. With the resources now on the table, Europe has no excuse not to deliver it.

Sources:

theamericanconservative.com, eda.europa.eu, war.gov, skribi.consilium.europa.eu, observe-europe.eu, cfr.org, carnegieendowment.org, cer.eu, eprs.europarl.europa.eu, csis.org